Did The Universe Have A Beginning?

An excellent question to ask an atheist or sceptic is, “Did the universe have a beginning?” There are only two answers available to the person who denies a theistic cause: “Yes, it created itself” or “No, it has existed eternally.”

Either answer, however, is deeply problematic on two fronts because each position violates both the laws of physics and some basic tenets of philosophy and logic.

  1. YES: It Created Itself

If the universe had a beginning but no Creator, then the only remaining possibility is that it somehow brought itself into existence.

Philosophically, this immediately raises an obvious problem: things don’t create themselves out of nothing. The Kalam Cosmological Argument posits that everything that begins to exist has a cause outside of itself. If our universe – consisting of space, time, matter and energy – came into existence at a finite point in the past, its cause cannot be itself, because before the universe existed there was nothing to do the creating. A universe cannot create itself because it would have to exist before it existed. That is a philosophical self-contradiction.

Scientifically, and more significantly, such a proposal also violates the Law of Conservation of Mass-Energy, one of the most fundamental principles of physics. This law states that mass and energy cannot be created or destroyed by natural processes; they can only be transformed from one form into another. Since all matter, energy, space, and time are part of the universe itself, there was no pre-existing reservoir of mass or energy from which the universe could naturally arise. The Law of Conservation of Mass-Energy simply does not allow mass and energy to be created out of nothing.

Some physicists have suggested that the universe arose from a “quantum vacuum” or through quantum fluctuations. However, a quantum vacuum is not “nothing.” It is a highly structured physical state governed by quantum fields and physical laws. Such proposals merely push the question back one step: where did the quantum fields, physical laws, and underlying reality come from?

Natural processes cannot create matter and energy from absolute nothingness. If the universe truly had a beginning, then its existence requires a cause beyond the natural order.

  1. NO: It Has Existed Eternally

The second alternative is that the universe has existed forever and therefore does not require an explanation for its beginning.

Philosophically, this proposal creates a profound conundrum. If the universe had existed forever, we would never have arrived at the present. If the universe had no beginning, then an actually infinite sequence of past events would have had to occur before the present moment could arrive. But an infinite sequence cannot be completed by successive addition. No matter how many past moments elapsed, infinitely more would still remain before reaching the present. Consequently, an eternal past cannot be traversed, making the present impossible. Yet here we are!

If you struggled to understand that last paragraph let me use the analogy of a time travel machine. If we started in the present and travelled back through time in a time machine, we could never reach infinity past because the timeline to infinity past has no end. That is the nature of infinity. Similarly, if we started in infinity past and travelled forward in time we could never reach today’s present.

Despite its obvious appeal to atheists, an eternally existing universe is a philosophically impossible proposition.

Scientifically, this proposal also encounters another fundamental law of physics: the Second Law of Thermodynamics. This law states that in every closed system the total entropy or usable energy available to do work tends to decrease over time. Energy becomes progressively more dispersed and less available. Systems naturally run down rather than wind themselves up.

If the universe had existed for an infinite amount of time, this process would already have run to completion. Every star would have exhausted its nuclear fuel. Every temperature difference would have disappeared and the universe would have reached thermodynamic equilibrium. No useful energy would remain to power stars, galaxies, or life. The universe would already be in a state of maximum entropy—a condition often referred to as “heat death.”

Yet this is clearly not what we observe. The universe still contains enormous quantities of usable energy. Stars continue to emanate heat and light, galaxies remain active, and complex structures still exist. The very fact that the universe has not reached thermodynamic equilibrium is powerful evidence that it has not existed forever but had a finite beginning.

Various attempts have been made to avoid this conclusion through theories such as oscillating universes, cyclic cosmologies, eternal inflation, or bubble universes. However, these models do not escape the problem. Either entropy accumulates from cycle to cycle, eventually making eternal cycles impossible, or the larger multiverse itself must still explain its own origin. In every case, the fundamental dilemma remains: either something comes from nothing, violating the conservation of mass-energy, or the universe has existed eternally, conflicting with the implications of the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Thus, both positions available to the non-theist regarding the origin of the universe are therefore deeply problematic.

A THIRD POSSIBILITY

There is, of course, a third possible answer to the question, “Did the universe have a beginning?” It is one that naturalists do not wish to consider but it is the answer that, I believe, science itself inexorably points towards:

  1. YES: It was created supernaturally.

If the laws of science preclude the previous two possibilities – that the universe has either always existed or that it created itself – then logically there is only one remaining possibility: the universe was created supernaturally (meaning “beyond nature”). Indeed, this conclusion seems inevitable, both philosophically and scientifically.

Philosophically, if we define the universe as consisting of all space, time, matter and energy then logically whatever created it had to be spaceless, timeless and immaterial. To put it even more simply, if nature had an origin, its cause must be beyond nature – which is what is meant by the term supernatural. Furthermore, this ultimate ‘first cause’ also had to be immensely powerful and intelligent. Does that ring any bells? A supernatural first cause that is spaceless, timeless, immaterial, all-powerful and intelligent? That sounds a lot like God to me!

Scientifically, when we examine the evidence available to us in the observable universe, what do we find? We discover strong evidence of intelligent design. We see this across the whole scale of the universe, from the micro-world of complex encoding in DNA and irreducibly complex molecular machines within cells to the macro-world of the finely tuned cosmological constants that govern the functioning of the cosmos.

The naturalist, on the other hand, when they examine the scientific evidence, is left with a growing list of unanswered (and, I believe, unanswerable) problems. These include the following: The impossibility of non-living matter giving rise to biological life. The impossibility of inanimate matter giving rise to consciousness. The impossibility of random natural processes creating the vast amounts of information in DNA. The absence of any natural mechanism for producing the finely balanced cosmological constants of our universe. And many more.

When the observable evidence is considered as a whole, the creationist worldview offers a coherent explanation for why there is a universe at all, why it had a beginning, why it is governed by elegant mathematical laws, why it appears finely tuned for life, and why living organisms contain vast quantities of specified, intelligent information. Naturalism, by contrast, must continually appeal to increasingly speculative hypotheses while leaving its most fundamental questions unanswered.

Renowned secular cosmologist, Alexander Vilenkin, famously wrote:

“It is said that an argument is what convinces reasonable men and a proof is what it takes to convince even an unreasonable man. With the proof now in place, cosmologists can no longer hide behind the possibility of a past-eternal universe. There is no escape—they have to face the problem of a cosmic beginning.” (Vilenkin, A. Many Worlds in One. New York: Hill and Wang, 2006, p. 176.)

This is an extraordinary admission from one of the world’s (then) leading cosmologists.

So, did the universe have a beginning? It’s a great question to ask someone. Go ahead. Give it a try and see where the conversation leads.

FURTHER RESOURCES:

Books: No More Monkey Business: Evolution in Crisis and 7 Reasons To Believe

Videos: Evidence For Belief